Ok, here’s the deal. I am a huge fan of the original Van Halen. This would be the band with David Lee Roth at its front. To me, the band was mostly about Dave. Even with the brilliance of Eddie on guitar, I was primarily a fan of the band because of Dave (who Dimebag Darrell once referred to as the baddest front man ever in rock ‘n roll). When Sammy took the reins, my interest in the band dropped. I don’t blame Sammy. I don’t even dislike like him. In fact, I was already a fan of his because of Montrose (a band famous to those of us of a certain age…), though I didn’t care all that much about his solo work before VH.
Anyway, back to Dave. I am also a huge fan of Dave’s solo stuff… at least up until the recent bluegrass record (which I can’t really comment on as I haven’t heard any of it except for what he performed on the Tonight Show which I thought was mediocre at best). I think Dave’s videos were all amazing and that he never got the credit he deserved for them. I loved DaveTV and everything he did with MTV. I also loved his performances on radio with Howard Stern. However, I can’t speak to his short-lived stint as Howard’s replacement as I didn’t get to hear it in Chicago.
Now that my love of Dave is understood by all, let me tell you that I saw Dave a couple of years ago at a fairly big local festival. As local festivals go, this is as big as they get in the Chicagoland area… but, it was still a local festival show. On one hand, this is admirable as he is still rockin’ and making a living as a musician, but on the other hand, it is kind of sad from a “Oh how the mighty have fallen” point-of-view.
Well, the show was ok. It wasn’t brilliant, but it certainly didn’t suck and based on that performance, there is no reason to think the new Van Halen with Dave back at it’s helm would be terrible or anything as a result. However, I am completely afraid that the new Van Halen with Dave back at it’s helm is going to be terrible. I hope I am wrong. I want to be wrong. However, my prediction is that it won’t really work. In fact, I’d be surprised if they complete the tour.
BTW, in case you were wondering, I refer to this incarnation as VH 3.5 because version one is the original line-up. V2 is with Sammy. V3 is with Gary Cherone (who I think was unjustly and quite harshly criticized … it was a no-win situation for anyone who might have taken the role as new singer and the fact that the record sucked I blame fully on Eddie and not Gary). This version could be considered V4 with Wolfgang taking Michael Anthony’s place, but I don’t think it qualifies. If they last for more than a year, then I’ll bump them up to V4.